During the setup with a new phone service, I ended up with two gmail addresses. sjmahuta@gmail.com which is the one I use and sjmahuta5@gmail.com...

Hello and welcome to ExpertHelp.com! My name is Ferdinand Aquino and I'm going to do everything in my power to answer your question to your full satisfaction!

Before we get started, I want to remind you ExpertHelp.com is an independent professional support company. We are not associated with Google nor are we paid to provide support on their behalf. However, we have helped hundreds of customers with similar questions and believe we can help you too. OK, let’s get started! :)

I’m available to chat now. Please let me know that you are ready by posting a response. I’ll leave my chat session open for the next 15 minutes or so and wait for your reply. If I don’t catch you this time, please respond with a few times (including your timezone) that work best for you and we can connect then.

 Hi Steve,

THank you for waiting!

What is the model or what phone are you using where showing 2 Gmail addresses?

Dear Steve, It was a pleasure helping you with your Gmail issue today. Here is a summary of the resolution.
Issue identified :

Accidentally signed in two gmail addresses 

Solution Implemented :

Call customer

Assisted in going to the phone's settings > Accounts > Google

Found two accounts, Click the one he wants removed and clicked the options button

Selected Remove Account

Tested going in to playstore

Now showing just one Gmail and is the correct one.

Issue resolved

If issue resurfaces in next 30 days, come back to this Question page and let me know. If you are unable to find your way back to this Question page or if you have billing questions, please contact our customer support either by email (s**t@experthelp.com) OR call us at ***-***-****